When Leadership Makes You the Hero and the Villain

Leadership is never one-sided.

Every decision you make, every stand you take, will paint you as a hero to some and a villain to others. That’s not a flaw. That’s the job. 

Neutral leaders don’t exist. If you’re leading, you’re moving people, disrupting comfort zones, and driving change.

The moment you do that, you step into someone’s story as either their savior or their scapegoat.  

The Hero Trap, the Villain Fear 

Many leaders fall into the trap of wanting to be seen only as the hero, always liked and always admired. It feels safer, more comfortable, and more rewarding to be praised than questioned. Leadership is not about being universally liked. Being liked and being effective are not the same thing. 

The other side of this trap is fear. Leaders fear being labeled the villain, the one who delivers bad news, makes unpopular calls, or disrupts people’s comfort zones. That fear can paralyze decision-making. It can push leaders to soften standards, delay necessary actions, or seek approval instead of progress. 

Ironically, the more leaders avoid the villain label, the more they risk becoming ineffective and eventually resented. Teams respect clarity and conviction far more than avoidance. 

The truth is simple. The fear of being the villain is natural, but it cannot be the driver. Leaders must accept that they will be both hero and villain, sometimes in the same day, and that what matters is not the label but the integrity behind the action.

Being the Hero 

Every leader wants to be the hero. It feels good to be admired, to be the one who inspires, protects, and creates opportunities. When teams are winning, when results are clear, when growth is visible, leaders are celebrated as heroes. 

But the danger lies in chasing hero status at all costs. When the desire to be liked outweighs the commitment to be effective, leaders start compromising. Standards are lowered, conflict is avoided, and progress is delayed. The pursuit of being “only the hero” weakens leadership. 

Being the Villain 

On the other side is the reality of being seen as the villain. Leaders do not want to be the one who delivers bad news, makes unpopular calls, or disrupts comfort zones. Yet leadership requires all of these. 

The truth is simple. Tough decisions always create tension. What benefits the organization may hurt an individual. One person’s promotion is another’s disappointment. Ending a failing project may save resources but frustrate a team. 

Even with the best intentions, someone will view a leader as the villain. And the more leaders try to avoid that role, the more ineffective they become. Teams respect clarity and conviction far more than avoidance. 

Accepting the Dual Role 

Here is the reality. Every leader will be both hero and villain, sometimes in the same day. That is not weakness, it is proof of impact. 

1. You cannot please everyone. 

2. Integrity outlasts popularity. 

3. Conflict can spark growth. 

4. Perception is beyond your control, but intent is not. 

   
   

The role of a leader is not to chase approval but to lead with clarity, courage, and care. What matters is whether decisions are made with integrity and responsibility. 

The Question Every Leader Must Answer 

So what are you? Are you chasing the illusion of being only the hero? Or are you ready to accept both roles, the hero and the villain, and lead with the integrity that real leadership demands? 

At ALVIGOR, we remind leaders that greatness comes not from being loved by everyone, but from being trusted to do what is right. We help leaders navigate the tension of being both hero and villain, building the clarity, courage, and integrity needed to lead with impact. 

👉 Ready to strengthen your leadership journey? Contact us today and let’s start shaping the way you lead. 

Book a Leadership Session